The Complexities of In-Kind Subscriptions in Investment Funds

The Intricacies of Subscriptions in Specie

In the diverse world of investment funds, the concept of subscriptions in specie stands out for its complexity and unique challenges. This method, where investors contribute assets other than cash – be it real estate, shares, or artworks – in exchange for fund units, opens a door to sophisticated investment strategies. However, it also navigates a terrain riddled with valuation challenges, especially in hard-to-value asset classes.
Valuation Challenges in Hard-to-Value Assets

The crux of in-kind subscriptions lies in valuing the contributed assets. This becomes particularly intricate for assets where market prices are elusive – think of a rare piece of art or a unique real estate property. The absence of a readily available market price demands a meticulous and expert approach to valuation, ensuring fairness and transparency for all fund stakeholders.
The Depositary's Pivotal Role

In the European Union, under frameworks like the AIFMD, the depositary's role in in-kind transactions is not just important but essential. The depositary acts as the guardian of compliance, ensuring that the entire process aligns with the fund's rules and the overarching legal landscape.
Ensuring Compliance and Fair Valuation

The depositary's first order of business is to ensure that the valuation of the non-cash asset is fair, adhering to the fund's valuation policy and protecting the interests of all investors. This often involves overseeing or facilitating an independent valuation, a step that is crucial in maintaining transparency and equity.
Asset Verification and Safekeeping

Beyond valuation, the depositary is responsible for verifying the ownership of the contributed assets and ensuring their safekeeping. This might involve complex processes like checking title documents or arranging for the secure transfer and registration of the assets.
Balancing Interests and Managing Risks

The depositary also plays a critical role in managing potential conflicts of interest and assessing the market risks associated with the contributed assets. This careful balancing act is key to maintaining the fund’s risk profile and safeguarding investor interests.
The Bigger Picture: Strategic Advantages and Risks

Subscriptions in specie open up strategic avenues for investment funds. They allow investors to partake in fund opportunities without the need for significant liquid capital, aligning with more flexible investment strategies. However, this flexibility comes with its share of challenges – notably, the impact on the fund’s liquidity profile and the overarching market risks.

The landscape of in-kind subscriptions in investment funds, especially for hard-to-value assets, is one marked by sophistication and complexity. The role of the depositary in navigating this landscape is indispensable, ensuring that such transactions are carried out with fairness, compliance, and a keen eye on risk management. As the investment world evolves, embracing such nuanced methods of investment, the role of rigorous valuation and careful oversight only grows in importance, underpinning the integrity and success of investment funds.

Rachel Ferrante
Depositary manager

Dolfin Europe is an independent investment platform offering execution, custody, and depositary services to private and institutional clients from across the world. Our comprehensive infrastructure enables our clients to benefit from first-class integrated solutions and a network of well-regarded service providers in Malta and wider Europe.
For more information, please visit